Journal Search Engine
Search Advanced Search Adode Reader(link)
Download PDF Export Citaion korean bibliography PMC previewer
ISSN : 2287-5824(Print)
ISSN : 2287-5832(Online)
Journal of The Korean Society of Grassland and Forage Science Vol.35 No.3 pp.245-250
DOI : https://doi.org/10.5333/KGFS.2015.35.3.245

Comparison of Forage Production and Nutritional Value of Italian ryegrass,Rye and Whole Crop Barley as Winter Forage Crops in Southern Region of Korea

Min Jeong So1, Hyeon Shup Kim1, Ji Hye Kim1, Sang-Hoon Lee1, Ki-Won Lee1, Jeong Sung Jung1, Kyung-Il Sung2, Jing lun Peng2, Hyung Soo Park1*
1National Institute of Animal Science, Cheonan, 330-801, Korea
2Department of Feed Science and Technology, Kangwon National University
*Correspondingauthor:Hyung Soo Park National Institute of Animal Science RDA, Cheonan 330-801, Korea. Tel: +82-41-580-6753, E-mail: anpark69@korea.kr
August 26, 2015 September 4, 2015 September 6, 2015

Abstract

This study was conducted from October 2014 to May 2015 to explore forage production and feed values of Italian ryegrass, Rye and whole crop barley as winter forage crops in the Southern region of Korea. The experimental location was over 10 points for each species and each sampling point area was 1 m2 (Width: 1 m × Length: 1 m). Air mean temperature and rainfall in the Southern region of Korea during the experimental period was 6.95 ± 5.75°C and 70.45 ± 54.68 mm, respectively. Fresh forage yield of Italian ryegrass, the most cultivated forage in the Southern region of Korea, was 44.4 ± 7.0 ton/ha. The percentage of dry matter for whole crop barley was 28.9 ± 7.0%. Crude protein (CP) was higher in Italian ryegrass (10.7 ± 5.3%) while total digestible nutrient (TDN) had the highest value in whole crop barley. Crude protein was not significantly different by location. However, the neutral detergent fiber (NDF), acid detergent fiber (ADF) and total digestible nutrient value of forage from Jeonbuk province were higher than in forage from Gyeongnam province.


초록


    Rural Development Administration
    No. PJ009766042015

    I.INTRODUCTION

    The livestock industry in Korea is facing difficulties due to high production cost and worldwide competition. For these reasons, the government has offered a variety of national policies in order to reduce the production cost of farm. Despite efforts of the government, forage selfsufficiency stopped at 82%. The main causes were problem of equal quality forage production by four seasons, competition with economic crops and high price of machine. In this background, the livestock industry has been continuously depending on the import of hay. In order to increase self-sufficiency and a stable production. Therefore, the study of roughage is required about forage production and domestic forage database. Recently, studies have been carried out a cold-tolerant and early-heading Italian ryegrass (Choi et al., 2006), cultivation and utilization barley as the main winter crop in paddy field (Kim and Seo, 2006) in Korea.

    Winter type forages have optimum growth temperature at 15~21 ℃, although it occurs summer depression when the air temperature rises more than over 25 ℃ (Kim, 1992). In addition, even rainfall conditions are optimal conditions for its growth.

    Annual average air temperature of Southern province in Korea is higher than central province. The range of average annual air temperature has 0 to 10 ℃ and range of annual average rainfall has 1,000 to 1,800 mm. Variation of winter temperature in climate of Southern provinces in Korea was lower than compared to central province, Southern province climate in Korea is characterized better on winter type forage optimal growth conditions because of the high rainfall compared to central province. Based on climate conditions and policies for domestic forage, studies were conducted that evaluation of characteristics, winter survival and forage production for warm season grass in the mid-Southern regions of Korea (Park et al., 2014). Evaluated characteristics and forage production for Bermudagrass (Cynodon dactylon) and Bahiagrass (Paspalum notatum) in Jeju (Park et al., 2012) and summer crops research by province for grasses mapping in Korea. However, studies of winter type grasses on Southern province have been not performed that compared to summer type grasses.

    Therefore, the purpose of the present study was performed to evaluate the forage production and nutritive value of Italian ryegrass, Rye and Whole crop barley and to utilize as a basis database in Korea Southern province.

    II.MATERIALS AND METHODS

    This experiment was performed from October 2014 to May 2015 at field and paddy field in Gyeongnam, Jeonbuk and Jeonnam provinces, Korea. The experiment species were winter type graminae grasses (Italian ryegrass, Rye and Whole crop barley) and the experiment was conducteded planting grasses in October 2014 as a target. The sampling place and weight were over 10 places, over 2 kg each grass, respectively and each sampling plot was 2 m2 (1.5 × 4 m). Fresh plant weight was calculated after cutting each sampling plot and it was converted to the number per ha. Dry matter yield was measured collecting 300 to 500 g per 2 kg each treatment, all dry matter rates of samples were calculated by oven drying at 68 ℃ for more than 72 hours. Then these samples were used for chemical composition analysis after crushing and filtered using 20 mesh sieves. The crude protein (CP) was analyzed according to AOAC (1990) method using KjeltecTM 2400 autosampler system (FOSS, Hillerød, Denmark). Neutral detergent Fiber (NDF) and acid detergent fiber (ADF) were analyzed by Goering and Van Soest (1970) using Ankom fiber analyzer (Ankom technology, New York, USA) (Ankom, 2005a; 2005b). Data were analyzed using the MIXED procedure of SAS Institute (ver. 9.1) (Littell et al., 2006) as a completely randomized design. Model was,

    Y = μ + Ti + Eij

    Where, μ is average value, Ti is treatment value, Eij is the error value. The fixed effect was supplement effect; random effect was not considered in procedure. Significant differences among the treatments were determined at p<0.05 whereas a trend was expressed when p<0.10 using Duncan’s multiple comparisons. All means presented were least square means.

    III.RESULT AND DISCUSSION

    1.Climate characteristics

    Air mean temperature and rainfall data of experimental sites during experimental period were presented in Fig. 1. Air mean temperature showed higher in the following order, Jeonnam > Gyeongnam > Jeonbuk province. Air mean temperature of each province such as Gyeongnam was 6.95 ± 5.64 ℃, Jeonbuk was 6.02 ± 6.11 ℃, Jeonnam was 7.86 ± 5.49°C, respectively. The average rainfall of each province Gyeongnam was 78.40 mm, Jeonbuk was 69.10 mm, Jeonnam was 69.86 mm, respectively. Murata and Iyama (1963) reported that winter type grasses have more photo synthesis rate at 10 to 15 ℃ and gradually reduced at 35 ℃. The respiration and growth characteristics of winter type grasses were no significant difference between 0 and 15 ℃. As range of air temperature on Southern province in Korea showed within 0 to 15 ℃. Air temperature was not considered to inhibit the growth of winter type grasses. As range of air temperature on Southern province in Korea 1.5 to 20.2 ℃ (Average, 9.58 ± 7.13 ℃), it was considered suitable temperature for growth of winter type grasses.

    2.Forage productivity

    Forage productivity of Italian ryegrass, Rye and Whole crop barley in Korea Southern province was shown in Table 1. Winter type grasses used for the experiment were reported that have high cold resistance. Dry matter percentage was higher in whole crop barley (28.9 ± 7.0%) compared to other plants. In this result, Italian ryegrass was considered as most grown winter type grass in the Southern Korea.

    Dry matter rate of Rye produced in Korea Southern province showed 24.7%, it was higher than value of previous studies (Alibes et al., 1990; Djouvinov et al., 1998) as 16.8%. Dry matter rate of whole crop barley produced in Korea Southern province showed 28.9%, in previous studies showed that range of dry matter rate was 15.0 to 41.5% (Ait Amar, 2005; Carr et al., 2003; Chow et al., 2008).

    Forage productivity of Italian ryegrass between Gyeongnam and Jeonbuk province was shown in Table 2. Forage productivity of Italian ryegrass in Gyeongnam province was higher than Jeonbuk province (P<0.05). This result was considered that due to air mean temperature, rainfall and soil temperature were higher in Gyeongnam province than Jeonbuk province. However, because of the result considered only cultivation location, this result was considered to require no further studies in consideration of the manure information and additional cultivation environment.

    Forage productivity of Rye between Gyeongnam and Jeonbuk province was shown in Table 3. Forage productivity of Rye in Gyeongnam province was higher than Jeonbuk province except for plant height (P<0.05). In dry matter rate, it considered that air mean temperature, rainfall and soil temperature of Gyeongnam province were higher than Jeonbuk province, for the same reason as Italian ryegrass.

    Forage productivity of whole crop barley between Jeonbuk and Jeonnam province was shown in Table 4. The results showed no significant difference between Jeonbuk and Jeonnam province on plant height and dry matter rate. However, dry matter yield of whole crop barley in Jeonbuk province was higher than Jeonnam province (P<0.05). These results were considered that whole crop barley cultivation amount in Jeonbuk province was higher than Jeonnam province. In plant height and dry matter result, although variation of cultivation environment shown in Fig. 1 by location was considered have low effect on whole crop barley growth, it considered to required further studies in consideration of additional environment.

    3.Forage nutritive values of Italian ryegrass, Rye and Whole crop barley by location

    Forage nutritive values of Italian ryegrass, Rye and whole crop barley were shown in Table 5. In CP content of Italian ryegrass and Rye were similar, whole crop barley showed lowest CP value as 8.7%. The NDF and ADF of Rye were 61.4% and 38.7%, respectively, NDF and ADF content of Italian ryegrass and whole crop barley were similar. Hemicellulose was no difference among the grass species. Although, CP of Italian ryegrass, Rye and whole crop barley showed similar value, that showed lower values than the imported grasses by previous studies (CIRAD, 1991; AFZ, 2011; NRC, 2000). In NDF and ADF value, domestic winter type grasses were similar compared to the imported winter type grasses. Forage nutritive values of Rye between Gyeongnam and Jeonbuk province were shown in Table 6. The CP and hemicellulose were showed no difference between Gyeongnam and Jeonbuk province. Although NDF and ADF value was exhibited no difference between Gyeongnam and Jeonbuk province, result of Gyeongnam province tend to higher tendency than Jeonbuk province (P<0.10).

    IV.CONCLUSION

    This study was conducted to evaluate forage production and nutritive value of winter type grasses (Italian ryegrass, Rye and Whole crop barley) in Korea Southern province in October 2014 while May 2015. The Italian ryegrass is a winter type grasses produced more amount in Korea Southern province. The higher dry matter rate showed in Whole crop barley. Forage production was higher than Gyeongnam province compared to other province, There is no difference between Jeonbuk and Jeonnam province. In CP although, content of Italian ryegrass and Rye were similar, CP content standard deviation of Italian ryegrass was higher than Rye. In NDF and ADF, contents of Italian ryegrass and whole crop barley were similar, content of Rye was higher than others. Although, nutritive value of Rye in Gyeongnam and Jeonbuk province on Rye was exhibited no significantly difference, The nutritive value of Gyeongnam was tend to higher than Jeonbuk province. These results were considered that forage production and nutritive value by location difference were insignificant. In dry matter yield, whole crop barley have advantage than others. In CP content, Rye have advantage than others, based on the content of CP standard deviation. However, in NDF, ADF and hemicellulose, Italian ryegrass and whole crop barley has advantage than Rye. These results were considered that each forage have specific characteristic based on the results. Therefore, overall, these results were considered that potential of winter type grasses productivity was sufficient in Southern regions of Korea.

    Figure

    KGFS-35-245_F1.gif

    Air mean temperature and rainfall data of experimental sites during experimental period (Location indicated average of latitude and longitude at research areas in 2015; Gyeongnam province, 35º28’23.1”N 127º41’36.5”E; Jeonbuk province, 35º36’33.3”N 126º35’31.8”E; Jeonnam province, 34º41’42.9”N 127º27’19.5”E).

    Table

    Plant height and dry matter yield of Italian ryegrass, Rye, Whole crop barley in south province of Korea

    Plant height and dry matter yield of Italian ryegrass by location

    †Location indicated average of latitude and longitude in research areas; Gyeongnam province, 35°26’9.0”N 127°45’43.0”E; Jeonbuk province, 35°31’31.5”N 126°46’28.8”E
    ‡Standard error of the mean between location.

    Plant height and dry matter yield of rye by location

    †Location indicated average of latitude and longitude in research areas; Gyeongnam province, 35°26’9.0”N 127°45’43.0”E; Jeonbuk province, 35°31’31.5”N 126°46’28.8”E
    ‡Standard error of the mean between location.

    Plant height and dry matter yield of rye by location

    †Location indicated average of latitude and longitude in research areas; Gyeongnam province, 35°26’9.0”N 127°45’43.0”E; Jeonbuk province, 35°31’31.5”N 126°46’28.8”E
    ‡Standard error of the mean between location.

    Crude protein, acid detergent fiber, neutral detergent fiber and hemicellulose of Italian ryegrass, Rye and whole crop barley

    †DM, dry matter; CP, crude protein; NDF, neutral detergent fiber; ADF, acid detergent fiber; TDN, total digestible nutrient.

    Crude protein, acid detergent fiber, neutral detergent fiber and hemicellulose of rye by location

    †Location indicated average of latitude and longitude in research areas; Gyeongnam province, 35°26’9.0”N 127°45’43.0”E; Jeonbuk province, 35°31’31.5”N 126°46’28.8”E
    ‡Standard error of the mean between location.

    Reference

    1. AFZ io - La Banque de données de l'Alimentation Animale French feed database (2011) Association Fran aise de Zootechnie,
    2. Alibes X , Tisserand JL (1990) Tables of the nutritive value forruminants of Mediterranean forages and by-products , Options Méditerranéennes : Série B Etudes et recherches; numero 4. CIHEAM, pp.-152
    3. Ait Amar B (2005) Production, utilisation et caractérisation de la valeur nutritive des fourrages et sous produits des cultures au Maroc , Mémoire. Institut Agronomique et Veterinaire Hassan II, Rabat (Morocco), pp.-112
    4. Ankom Technology (2005a) Method for determining neutral detergentfiber. ANKOM Technology Fairport NY. http://www.ankom.com/09_procedures /procedures2.shtml Accessed. May 8 2005 ,
    5. Ankom Technology (2005b) Method for determining acid detergent fiber , ANKOM echnology Fairport NY. http://www.ankom.com/09_procedures /proceduresl.shtml Accessed May 8, 2005,
    6. AOAC (1990) Official Methods of Analysis, Association of Official Analytical Chemists,
    7. Carr PM , Horsley RD , Poland WW (2003) Forages: barley,oat, and cereal pea mixtures as dryland forages in the Northern Great Plains , Agronomy Journal, Vol.96 (3) ; pp.677-684
    8. Choi GJ , Lim YC , Rim YW , Sung BR , Kim MJ , Kim KY , Seo S (2006) A Cold-Tolerant and Early-Heading Italian Ryegrass New Variety, ‘Kogreen’ , Journal of The Korean Societyof Grassland and Forage Science, Vol.26; pp.9-14
    9. Chow LO , Baron VS , Corbett R , Oba M (2008) Effects ofplanting date on fiber digestibility of whole-crop barley and productivity of lactating dairy cows , Journal of Dairy Science, Vol.91 (4) ; pp.1534-1543
    10. CIRAD (1991) Laboratory data 1963-1991 , CIRAD,
    11. Djouvinov DS , Nakashima Y , Todorov N , Pavlov D (1998) In-situ degradation of feed purines , Animal Feed Science and Technology, Vol.71 (1-2) ; pp.67-77
    12. Goering HK , Van Soest PJ (1970) Forage fiber analysis , Ag. Handbook. No. 379, ARS,
    13. Kim DA (1992) Factors required to sustain pastoral farming systems and forage supply in winter cold zones in Korea , Journal of The Korean Society of Grassland and Forage Science, Vol.12; pp.30-40
    14. Kim WH , Seo S (2006) Cultivation and Utilization Barley asthe Main Winter Crop in Paddy Field , Journal of The Korean Society of Grassland and Forage Science, pp.37-57
    15. Littell RC , Milliken GA , Stroup WW , Wolfinger RD , Schbenberger O (2006) SAS for Mixed Models , SAS Institute,
    16. Murata Y , Iyama J (1963) Studies on the Photosynthesis of Forage Crops: II. Influence of air-temperature upon the photosynthesis of some forage and grain crops , National Institute of Agricultural Science, Vol.31; pp.315-322
    17. National Research Council Clean Coastal Waters (2000) Understanding and Reducing the Effects of Nutrient Pollution , National Academies Press ,
    18. Park HS , Hwang KJ , Park NG , Choi GJ , Lee JK , Cheon DW , Ko MS (2008) Comparison of forage production and feed value of winter forage crops in Jeju , Journal of The Korean Society of Grassland and Forage Science, Vol.32; pp.37-57 pp.131-138